Okay it might be the most over-done Magic craft ever, but I baked M:TG colored cookies for my local FNM (actually, Saturday night, because we’re cool like that). The frosting was the best part.
- Red: White chocolate red raspberry truffle
- Green: White chocolate almond
- Blue: Blue gel frosting (cheated and bought it)
- White: White chocolate drizzle
- Black: Dark chocolate
I was originally going to add food color to the cookies themselves, but I wasn’t sure anyone would want to eat a green or blue cookie. The sugar cookie recipe came out awesome, and you can try it here.